The history of the examination for state of alcohol intoxication
Abstract
Evolution of the approaches to diagnostics of DUI as the evidentiary base in law violations is traced; parallelism in the development of scientific beliefs on the nature of acute alcohol intoxication, scientific and technological achievements – on one hand, and legislation in the field of traffic safety, on the other is described Two principles of diagnostics are compared – clinical and chemical-toxicological, their advantages and disadvantages. Author’s point of view concerning optimal principles of diagnostics and legislation in Russia is formulated.
About the Authors
T. O. Barinskaya
Drug clinical hospital № 17 of Moscow Department of health
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
PhD, doctor of clinical laboratory diagnostics
A. A. Burtsev
Drug clinical hospital № 17 of Moscow Department of health
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
head of the department of drug testing
A. V. Smirnov
Drug clinical hospital № 17 of Moscow Department of health
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
PhD, head of laboratory of chemistry and toxicology
A. E. Petukhov
Drug clinical hospital № 17 of Moscow Department of health
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
PhD, doctor of clinical laboratory diagnostics
References
1. Баринская Т.О. Химико-токсикологическое исследование кинетики этанола в крови, выдыхаемом воздухе, слюне и моче (к медицинскому освидетельствованию на состояние опьянения) // Диссертация на соискание ученой степени кандидата фармацевтических наук. – Москва, 2011.
2. Баринская Т.О., Смирнов А.В., Саломатин Е.М., Шаев А.И. Кинетика этанола в биологических средах. Ж. «Судебно-медицинская экспертиза», 2006 г., № 1, стр. 27 – 32.
3. Баринская Т.О., Смирнов А.В., Саломатин Е.М., Шаев А.И. Соотношения концентрации этанола в выдыхаемом воздухе и крови после однократного приема алкоголя. – Ж. Наркология, 2008, № 1.
4. Баринская Т.О., Смирнов А.В., Саломатин Е.М., Шаев А.И., Морозов Ю.Е. Кинетика этанола в биологических средах // Наркология. – 2007. – № 5. – С. 50 – 57.
5. Кодекс Российской Федерации об административных правонарушениях, раздел IV, статья 27.12, статья 7, примечание (отменено с 26.06.2010 г.).
6. Латепков В.П. Хронопатофизиология острой алкоголизации //Тез. докл. 4 Всесоюзного съезда патофизиологов. – Кишинев, Москва, 1989. – Т. 1. – С. 396.
7. Латепков В.П. Хронотоксикология алкоголя // В сб. «Хронобиология и хронопатология: тез. докл.». – М., 1981. – С. 146.
8. Медицинское освидетельствование для установления факта употребления алкоголя и состояния опьянения (методические указания). Утверждено зам. Министра здравоохранения СССР А.М. Москвичевым 01.09.1988 г.
9. Приказ Минздрава РФ от 14 июля 2003 г. N 308 "О медицинском освидетельствовании на состояние опьянения".
10. Bell C.M., Flack H.J. Examining Variables Associated with Sampling for Breath Alcohol Analysis. – http://www.druglibrary.org/schaffer/MISC/driving/s5p3.htm
11. Clarke’s Analysis of Drugs and Poisons in pharmaceuticals, body fluids and postmortem material. Fourth edition. London, Chicago: Pharmaceutical Press, 2011, 2473 p.
12. Dubowski K.M. Absorbtion, Distribution and Elimination of Alcohol: Highway Safety Aspects // Journal of Studies on Alcohol. Supp.– 1985. – Vol. 10. – P. 98 – 108.
13. Dubowski K.M. Biological Aspects of Breath-Alcohol Analysis // Clin. Chem. – 1974. – Vol. 20, № 2. – P.294 – 299.
14. Dubowski K.M. Studies in Breath-Alcohol Analysis: Biological Factors // International Journal of Legal Medicine. – 1975. Vol. 76. – P. 93.
15. Evans Leonard. Traffic Safety. Bloomfild Hills, MI; Science Serving Society, 2004.
16. Forensic Issues in Alcohol Testing. Ed. By Karch S.B., CRC Press, 2008, p. 21 – 64.
17. Fowler W. Lung Function Studies: The Respiratory Dead Space. American Journal of Physiology, 1948, v. 154, pp. 405-416.
18. Gainsford A.R., Fernando D.M., Lea R.A., Stowell A.R. A Large-Scale Study of the Relationship Between Blood and Breath Alcohol Concentrations in New Zealand Drinking Drivers // Journal of Forensic Sciences. – 2006 – Vol. 51, № 1. – P. 173 – 178.
19. Giorgetti R., Zancaner S., Brusini G., Castagna F., Fenato F., Rossi A., Ferrara S.D. // Low Blood Alcohol Concentrations and Psychomotor Performance in Tolerating and Non-Tolerating Subjects. www.druglibrary.org/schaffer/misc/driving/s22p4.htm
20. Gold C., Tichauer G.R., Wolkenberg R.C. Pharmacokinesiological study of alcohol hangover // Amer. Assosiation for Automotive Medicine, Proc. 17th. – Oklahoma City. 1973. – P. 351 – 363.
21. Gubala W., Zuba D. Comparison of Ethanol Pharmacokinetics in Blood, Breath and Saliva. – Drug and Alcohol Detection and Screening. – P. 1115-1122. http://www.saaq.gouv.qc.ca/t2002/actes/pdf/(34a).pdf
22. Gubala W., Zuba D. Gender differences in the pharmacokinetics of ethanol in saliva and blood after oral injestion. – Polish Journal of Pharmacology, 2003, v. 55, № 4, pp. 639-644.
23. Gubala W., Zuba D. Saliva as an alternative specimen for alcohol determination in the human body // Polish Journal of Pharmacology, 2002, v. 54, pp. 161 – 165.
24. Gubala W., Zuba D., Piekoszewski W. Variability of BAC/ BrAC, BAC/SAC and SAC/BrAC Ratios During Absorbtion and Elimination of Alcohol. – Drug and Alcohol Detection and Screening. – P. 1123-1127, http://www.saaq.qc.ca/t2002/actes/pdf/(34a).pdf
25. Hlastala M.P. Physiological Laws of Alcohol Breath Testing. – www.mphlastala/Physiological%20Lawsof%20ABT.pdf
26. Hlastala M.P. The Alcohol Breath Test – A Review // J. Appl. Physiol. – 1998. – Vol. 84, № 2. – P. 401 – 408.
27. Hlastala M.P. Why Breath Tests of Blood-Alcohol Don´t Work. – The Big Apple Seminar, May 25, 2001. – www.mphlastala.com/NYSBA%2001.pdf
28. Hlastala, M. P. A New Paradigm for the Alcohol Breath Test. DWI Journal, 1998, v. 13, pp. 1-7.
29. Hlastala, M. P. Breathing Related Limitations to the Alcohol Breath Test. DWI Journal: Science and Law, 2001, v. 17, pp. 1-4.
30. Hlastala, M. P. Physiological Errors Associated with Breath Alcohol Testing. The Champion, 1985, July, pp. 16-19.
31. Hlastala, M. P. Physiology of Alcohol in the Body. Trial News, 1988, v. 23, № 8, pp. 2-14.
32. Hlastala, M. P. The Alcohol Breath Test. Journal of Applied Physiology, 2002, v. 93, pp. 405-406.
33. http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/Определение_содержания_алкоголя_в_крови
34. http://www.alcotest.ru/company/
35. Intoximeters. Over 60 Years in the Breath Alcohol Testing Field http://www.intox.com/aboutus.asp
36. Jones A.W. Alcohol and driving – The road ahead. Proceedings 17th International Conference on Alcohol, Drugs and Traffic Safety, Glasgow, Scotkand, 2004, 6 pp.
37. Jones A.W. Blood and breath alcohol concentrations // B.M.J. – 1992/ – Vol. 305. – P. 955.
38. Jones A.W. Effect of temperature and humidity of inhaled air on the concentration of ethanol in a man´s exhaled breath // Clin. Sci. – 1982. – Vol. 63. – P. 441 – 445.
39. Jones A.W. Erik M.P. Widmark – Bridged the gap between forensic toxicology and alcohol and traffic safety research // Annals de Toxicologie Analytique, 2007, vol. XIX, № 4, pp. 294 – 295.
40. Jones A.W. How Breathing Technique Can Influence the Results of Breath-Alcohol Analysis // Medicine, Science, and Law. – 1982. – Vol. 24, № 4. – P. 275.
41. Jones A.W. Pharmacokinetics of Ethanol in Saliva: Comparison with Blood and Breath Alcohol Profiles, Subjective Feelings of Intoxication, and Diminished Performance // Clinical Chemistry. – 1993. – Vol. 39, № 9. – P. 1837-1844.
42. Jones A.W., Andersson L. – Variability of the Blood/Breath Ratio in Drinking drivers. – Journal of Forensic Sciences, 1996, 41, № 6, 916-921.
43. Jones A.W., Andersson L. Comparison of ethanol concentrations in venous blood and end-expired breath during a controlled drinking study. – Forensic Sci. Int., 2003, v. 132, № 1, pp. 18-25.
44. Jones A.W., Jönsson K. Å. Between-subject and within-subject variations in the pharmacokinetics of ethanol // Br. J. Clin. Pharmac. – 1994. – V. 37, – p. 427 – 431.
45. Jones A.W., Jönsson K.Å., Jorfeldt L. Differences between Capillary and Venous Blood-Alcohol Concentrations as a Function of Time after drinking, with Emphasis on Sampling Variations in Left vs Right Arm // Clin. Chem. – 1989. – Vol. 35, № 3. – P. 400-404.
46. Jones A.W., Lindberg L., Olsson SG. -Magnitude and time-course of arterio-venous differences in blood-alcohol concentration in healthy men. – Clin. Pharmacokinet., 2004, v. 43, № 15, 1157-1166.
47. Lewis K.O. Back calculation of blood alcohol concentration // British medical journal, 1987, v. 295, pp. 800 – 801.
48. Lindberg L., Brauer S., Wollmer P., Goldberg L., Jones A.W., Olsson S-G. Breath alcohol concentration determined with a new analyzer using free exhalation predicts almost precisely the arterial blood alcohol concentration // Forensic Sci. Int. – 2007. – Vol. 168, № 2-3. – P. 200-207.
49. Lion Alcolmeter™ S-D2. Operating Instruction Manual. – 1995. – Lion Laboratories plc, A1.4.
50. Lowrell H. Effects of small doses of alcohol in driver performance in emergency traffic situation // Accid. Anal. & Prev. – 1974, – V. 9, № 3
51. Lowrell H., Törrros J. Hang-over effects of alcohol on driver performance // 1982.
52. Martin E., Moll W., Schmid P., Dettli L. The pharmacokinetics of alcohol in human breath, venous and arterial blood after oral ingestion. – Eur. J. Clin. Pharmacol., 1984, v. 26, № 5, pp. 619-626.
53. Mason M.F., Dubowski K.M. Breath-alcohol analysis: uses, methods, and some forensic problems – review and opinion // J. Forensic Sci. – 1976. – Vol. 21, № 1. –P. 9 – 41.
54. Moynham A.F., Perl J., Anderson S.G., Jennings S.R., Starmer G.A. Evidential Breath Analysis in New South Wales: An Exercise in Pragmatism. http://casr.adelaide.edu.au/T95/paper/s5p5.html
55. National safety council. A history of the committee on alcohol and other drugs (CAOD) http://downloads.nsc.org/pdf/NSChistoryofCAOD.pdf
56. Rahn, H. Mahoney J., Otis A. B. and Fenn, W. O. A Method for the Continuous Analysis of Alveolar Air. Journal of Aviation Medicine, 1946, v. 7, pp. 173-178.
57. Seppälä T. et al. Effects of hangover on psychomotor skills related to driving: modification by fructose and glucose // Acta Pharmacol. et toxicol. – 1976, – V. 38. – P. 209 – 218.
58. Simpson C.D., Kerby J.A., Kerby S.E. Varing Length of Expiration Blow and End Result Breath Alcohol. International Journal of Drug Testing, 2007, v. 3, at http://www.owidefenselaw.com/DATAMASTER%20Michigan%20Breath%20Test%20Operator%202003%20Training%20Manual.pdf
59. Simpson G. Do Breath Test Really Underestimate Blood Alcohol Concentration? // J. Anal. Toxicol. – 1989. – Vol. 13, № 2. – P. 120.
Review
Views:
370
Email this article 